Eight years after he first shared it online, Kyoto University mathematician Shinichi Mochizuki's controversial, 600-page proof for a profound mathematical conjecture has been approved for publication in an academic journal.
But there's a twist: academic mathematicians around the world didn't believe that Mochizuki solved the problem, known as the "abc conjecture," back then, Nature Newsreports, and they remain unconvinced now.
If Mochizuki ends up being right, he could revolutionize number theory. But experts in the field don't think acceptance in a journal is nearly enough evidence.
The abc conjecture is an unproven - unless, of course, Mochizuki nailed it - mathematical concept with far-reaching implications.
It states that if there are two different numbers that can be divisible entirely into small prime numbers, then the sum of those two numbers is only divisible by a smaller number of larger prime numbers.
But no one has been able to verify his claims - the NYT reports that experts at the time compared the four papers to trying to decipher an alien language.
So they remain skeptical that an academic journal managed to succeed where the entire math community failed.
"If the best mathematicians spend time trying to work out what's going on and fail," an anonymous mathematician told the NYT, "how can one referee on his own have any chance?"
Gen. Raymond: "The COVID crisis must not undermine critical space industries."
WASHINGTON — The Space Acquisition Council, a senior level group created by Congress to oversee space procurements across the Defense Department, held an emergency meeting April 27 to discuss ways to support the space industry that has been hit hard by the pandemic.
Will Roper, assistant secretary of the Air Force for acquisition, technology and logistics, chairs the council. In a statement, he said the group is working to “assess sectors most impacted by the pandemic while creating an environment where companies in need can compete fairly in the event of supplemental federal relief funds.”
“Our space industrial base is critical to our military and economy,” said Roper. The emergency session was to “synchronize our response to fragile supply chains, at risk workforces, and receding commercial markets and we’ll continue to work with the Department of Defense and Congress to get additional help.”
Roper said the council directed a survey go out to space industrial base sectors, including members and non-members of the Space Enterprise Consortium, federally funded research and development centers and think tanks.
The survey will look at emerging supply chain, cleared workforce, and markets under immediate distress. Another goal is to understand the impact of COVID-19 on program schedules and determine what stimulus can be provided to sectors like small space vehicles sand micro-electronics.
National Reconnaissance Office Director Christopher Scolese said the NRO will work with the Space Acquisition Council and with the U.S. Space Force to “ensure the stability of the space sector.”
While major suppliers have been affected by COVID-19, an immediate concern of the council are lower-tier suppliers and vendors, as well as small companies, especially in the small launch, commercial satellite communications, and micro-electronic sectors.
“The COVID crisis must not undermine critical space industries,” said Gen. Jay Raymond, U.S. Space Force Chief of Space Operations. “Given the threat to space capabilities posed by potential adversaries, we need to ensure the U.S. space industrial base remains strong.”
Scientists at the University of Southampton and Forest Research say understanding the risk of damage by deer to new and existing forests in Britain is crucial when considering their expansion.
The researchers analysed data from over 15,000 National Forest Inventory survey plots across Britain and, among other findings, showed the level of destruction deer cause isn't solely down to the concentration of their numbers in a given area. They concluded damage is also driven by a range of other important factors, such as climate, tree type and density, roads and, crucially, the amount of forest in the surrounding landscape.
The study is part of SCALEFORES, a €1.5m project funded by the European Research Council (ERC), and detailed findings are published in the Journal of Applied Ecology.
Ambitious targets for planting new woodland have been set in the UK. The Government has committed to planting up to 30,000 hectares of trees per year, across the UK, by 2025.1
Wild deer pose a significant threat to forests. They strip the leaves, shoots and bark of trees, decimate plant communities in the undergrowth, and prevent natural regeneration of trees.
Lead author, Dr Rebecca Spake, Research Fellow in Applied Biogeography at the University of Southampton, comments: "As we make plans to expand our forests in Britain, it becomes increasingly important to understand what drives damage by deer populations. New woodland needs protection from deer, but creating woodlands could also have knock-on effects on deer damage in another.
advertisement
"Our study shows how this understanding can be used to target costly mitigation efforts, such as fencing, to the right places."
Professor Felix Eigenbrod, study co-author, adds: "This study shows the importance of considering the wider landscape context when deciding where to plant the forests required to help meet the UK's ambitious climate change goals."
Ben Ditchburn, Programme Lead for the National Forest Inventory at Forest Research said: "This collaborative research provides a deep dive into our National Forest Inventory data, revealing hidden patterns and valuable new insights into deer behaviour that we would otherwise not be aware of."
Dr Chloe Bellamy, Forest Research, adds "Recent official national statistics from the National Forest Inventory highlighted the fact that 40 percent of British forests have 'unfavourable' levels herbivore damage, which limits the survival of young trees and threatens biodiversity. Our analysis shows where and why deer are likely to damage trees, information which is critical to targeting efforts to enhance forest cover and condition."
The researchers found that the amount of forest in the surrounding landscape was important in explaining the likelihood of damage to a site. However, this effect was not straightforward, and depended on regional deer density and climate, in addition to the surrounding cover of low vegetation. To communicate this complexity, the authors have launched an interactive Deer Damage Tool to help land managers investigate how afforestation may influence deer damage in different areas of the country, in addition to summarising their findings in a paper.
At a local level, there's an increased likelihood of deer foraging in unmanaged, broadleaved woodland which has relatively low numbers of trees and varies widely in age. This is likely due to greater ease of movement for the animals, an attractive layer of vegetation between trees for feeding and a preference for eating broadleaved species. Findings also showed, in agreement with previous studies, that roads deter deer from selecting surrounding habitats.
Dr Robin Gill, deer specialist at Forest Research comments: "These results will help us assess the risk of deer damage in the future, which is particularly important in the context of new policy initiatives to expand our forests to combat climate change."
The study authors used data from The National Forest Inventory field survey and deer density figures from the Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust's National Game Bag Census. From these, they modelled and mapped site susceptibility to deer damage.
Some of the most exciting discoveries in human evolution happened in the last decade. (Human Origins Program, Smithsonian Institution)
Human evolution is one of the most vibrant areas of scientific investigation. In the past decade we’ve seen many discoveries that add to our understanding of our origins. To mark the 10th anniversary of the Smithsonian’s “David H. Koch Hall of Human Origins,” here are some of the biggest discoveries in human evolution from the last 10 years.
We have ancient DNA
Scientists extracted ancient DNA from this 76,000-52,000-year-old fossil pinky bone in 2010, leading to the identification of the Denisovan population. (Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology)
DNA tells us a lot about who we are now. But we also look to ancient DNA to learn about our origins.
When the decade first started, scientists recovered ancient genetic material from a fossilized finger bone found in the Denisova Cave in Siberia. They tested that material and discovered that the DNA didn’t match that of modern humans or Neanderthals. Instead, it belonged to a previously undiscovered species of early humans now called Denisovans. It was the first time a new species has been identified using ancient DNA.
What does this tell us? The human genome is a wondrous archive of our relationships with ancient species no longer around.
Meet our new ancestors
737 fossils of Homo naledi, a new early human species announced in 2015. (Image by John Hawks/Courtesy of University of the Witwatersrand)
Over the past decade, we welcomed four new species to our family tree, including the mysterious Homo naledi.
In 2015, scientists announced the discovery of fossils of at least 15 individuals of this species in a deep, dark chamber of the Rising Star Cave system in South Africa. It's five years later and we still aren’t sure how they got there. There’s no evidence they were dragged there by predators or washed in by water. And no other animal bones were found in the cave except for the bones of a single owl. Were the bodies placed there deliberately? If so, by whom? It’s a mystery still to be solved.
What we do know is that the remains are from 335,000-236,000 years ago and show a unique mix of ancient and human traits, making Homo naledi one of several species that overlapped in time with our own.
Fossil discoveries tell more of our story
This 3.8-million-year-old cranium of Australopithecus anamensis helped scientists see how the face of an early human species looked. (Photograph by Dale Omori, courtesy of the Cleveland Museum of Natural History)
Not all fossil discoveries lead to a new species. But new fossils always reveal more of our story.
In the past ten years, we’ve found fossils that widen both the geographic and time range of several early human species. But one of the most exciting discoveries is of a nearly complete 3.8-million-year-old cranium of Australopithecus anamensis from Woronso-Mille, Ethiopia. Until this find was announced in 2019, researchers had only found bits and pieces of this species from various sites across Ethiopia and Kenya.
Fossils older than 3.5 million years are extremely rare. But what makes this discovery particularly amazing is that it challenges the previous assumption that A. anamensis was the direct ancestor of the species Australopithecus afarensis—to which the famous fossil “Lucy” belongs. Thanks to this skull, we now know that the two species overlapped in time.
We made tools earlier than we thought
A 3.3-million-year-old stone tool in situ at the Lomekwi 3 excavation site in Kenya. (Mission Préhistorique au Kenya/West Turkana Archaeological Project)
When you think of technology today, you might picture computers, smartphones, and gaming consoles. But for our ancestors millions of years ago, it would have been stone tools.
We long thought our ancestors began making these tools about 2.6 million years ago. But a discovery announced in 2015 pushed that date back. The research team found pieces of altered stone in Lomekwi, Kenya, that date to 3.3 million years ago. These stones are larger and simpler than those that were previously thought to be the oldest stone tools.
The new discovery suggests that the ability to flake stone tools arose at least 700,000 years before it became a regular habit in the lives of our ancestors.
We’re older than we thought
Reconstructions of the earliest known Homo sapiens fossils based on CT scans of multiple original fossils. (Philipp Gunz, MPI EVA Leipzig, License: CC-BY-SA 2.0)
Stone tools aren’t the only things that are older than we thought. Humans are too.
Just three years ago, a team of scientists made a discovery that pushed back the origin of our species, Homo sapiens. The team re-excavated a cave in Morocco where a group of miners found skulls in 1961. They collected sediments and more fossils to help them identify and date the remains. Using CT scans, the scientists confirmed that the remains belonged to our species. They also used modern dating techniques on the remains. To their surprise, the remains dated to about 300,000 years ago, which means that our species originated 100,000 years earlier than we thought.
Social Networking Isn’t New
Obsidian from Olorgesailie, Kenya revealed that social networks existed long before we thought. (Human Origins Program, Smithsonian Institution)
With platforms like Facebook, Twitter and Instagram, it hard to imagine social networking being old. But it is. And, now, it’s even older than we thought.
In 2018, scientists discovered that social networks were used to trade obsidian, valuable for its sharp edges, by around 300,000 years ago. After excavating and analyzing stone tools from southern Kenya, the team found that the stones chemically matched to obsidian sources in multiple directions of up to 55 miles away. The findings show how early humans related to and kept track of a larger social world.
We left Africa earlier than we thought
2.1-million-year-old stone tools from the site of Shangchen on the Loess Plateau of central China. (Zhu Zhaoyu, Chinese Academy of Sciences)
We’ve long known that early humans migrated from Africa not once but at least twice. But we didn’t know just how early those migrations happened.
We thought Homo erectus spread beyond Africa as far as eastern Asia by about 1.7 million years ago. But, in 2018, scientists dated new stone tools and fossils from China to about 2.1 million years ago, pushing the Homo erectus migration to Asia back by 400,000 years.
Also in 2018, researchers announced the discovery of an upper jaw in Israel that looked like that of our own species, Homo sapiens. The jaw ended up being 174,000-185,000 years old. This discovery—along with others from China and Greece—suggest that Homo sapiens wandered short-term into Eurasia well before the worldwide migration that began 70,000 years ago.
Briana Pobiner leads the National Museum of Natural History’s Human Origins Program’s education and outreach efforts and manages the Human Origins Program's public programs. Her research centers on the evolution of human diet (with a focus on meat-eating), but has included topics as diverse as human cannibalism and chimpanzee carnivory. Her favorite field moments include falling asleep in a tent in the Serengeti in Tanzania while listening to the distant whoops of hyenas, watching a pride of lions eat a zebra carcass on the Kenyan equator, and discovering fossil bones that were last touched, butchered and eaten by one of her 1.5-million-year-old ancestors.
Paleoanthropologist Dr. Rick Potts heads the Human Origins Program at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History. In partnership with the Kenya Museums, Potts leads ongoing excavations in southern and western Kenya. His research focuses on how environmental instability has affected human evolution and our evolutionary adaptations. He is the curator of the Smithsonian’s "Hall of Human Origins" and the traveling exhibit “Exploring Human Origins.” He also authored the exhibit companion book What Does It Mean To Be Human?
Quilty Analytics' Justin Cadman: “Most of the investment in the last three years has been from newer investors to the sector, some of whom will lack the stomach to continue.”
WASHINGTON — The U.S. military has come to rely on commercial companies and investors to develop next-generation space systems. The top official from the U.S. Space Force procurement arm, Lt. Gen. John Thompson, said in February that only 20 percent of the R&D investment in space now comes from the DoD and 80 percent from commercial investors.
A new report by the market research firm Quilty Analytics estimated that over the last five years approximately $11 billion of private funding went into space startups.
Venture financing will recede during the coronavirus economic recession, so one of the issues for the Pentagon is that investments it was counting on may no longer be there, said Justin Cadman, analyst at Quilty Analytics.
“We absolutely expect there to be continued investment in space. But the character of the investment will evolve,” Cadman told SpaceNews. The future is likely to bring a “reversal of that expansionary trend as we enter this COVID-19 induced recession.”
Of concern to national security space programs that rely on commercial technology is that “only a subset of space investors are battle-hardened veterans,” the Quilty Analytics report said. “Most of the investment in the last three years has been from newer investors to the sector, some of whom will lack the stomach to continue.”
Cadman said there are “some very high-quality companies that run the risk of disappearing for no other reason other than bad luck and timing.” Some of these companies are in the midst of developing innovative technologies with national security applications and suddenly “find themselves on the wrong side of the fundraising cycle as a result of this economic recession,” said Cadman.
Among some lucrative opportunities for space startups in the national security market, the report says, are the National Reconnaissance Office’s commercial imagery program, the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency’s Blackjack program and the Space Development Agency’s planned constellations in low Earth orbit.
Government contracts could provide a lifeline to some space companies but not all will make it through the crisis, said Cadman.
“We are cautiously optimistic about the prospects for venture space,” he said. “But undoubtedly there will be some shakeout.”
Todd Harrison, defense budget analyst and senior fellow at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, suggested that the Pentagon should identify “crown jewels’ they want to protect from economic calamity.
“Smaller space companies are really vulnerable, especially the space companies that the military expected to be there,” Harrison said last week during a SpaceNews online forum.
“For commercially oriented space companies, this economic downturn could not have hit at a worst time,” he said. Startups need capital in the early stages before they get revenue, Harrison said. “As a nation if we want to be competitive we don’t want to lose this vital part of the space industrial base.”
Listen carefully on a quiet summer night and you might hear them. Even if you don’t see a bat’s frantically fluttering form, you might catch its high-pitched chirp as it searches the night for dinner. You’re probably hearing a little brown bat, a common insect-eater found throughout North America, but it is just one of more than a thousand species of bat ranging from the one-inch-long Kitti’s hog-nosed bat to the enormous, three-pound giant golden-crowned flying fox.
Large or small, bats suffer a reputation problem. Aside from being associated with vampires, they’re often called “flying rats” and blamed for the spread of zoonotic diseases into humans (including COVID-19, though whether that blame is founded is as of yet unclear.) This fear often overshadows the fascinating fact that bats are the only mammals to have evolved powered flight, and they’ve been flapping around for tens of millions of years. Where, then, did these flying oddities come from?
Bats pop up in the fossil record around 50 million years ago during a time known as the Eocene. Paleontologists have recovered remains ranging from teeth and bits of jaw to stunning full skeletons in places as far-flung as Wyoming, Paris, Australia and India’s Vastan Mine.
Onychonycteris from Fossil Butte National Monument
(Wiki Commons)
There are some differences between the oldest bats and their modern relatives. Based upon the ear anatomy of the better-preserved specimens, for example, scientists know that the first bats couldn’t echolocate. They relied on sight, smell and touch to find their meals. While modern bats have a claw only on the equivalent of our thumb, earlier bats kept some of the additional finger claws inherited from their ancestors. A fossil bat dating to about 52 million years ago, dubbed Onychonycteris finneryi in 2008, had claws on all five of its fingers. New technology has added a few details to the early bat story, too. A recent study of coloration in the fossil record found that two 48 million-year-old bats found in Germany were mostly brown.
Despite these strides, scientists are left with some big questions. For one thing: The 50-million-year-old bat specimens are already recognizable as bats, so where did they come from? When, where, why and how the first bats become airborne is another mystery buried by Deep Time.
Paleontologists are familiar with such conundrums. For decades, anatomists and zoologists were confounded by the origin of whales. Then, at the end of the 20th century, a wealth of fossil finds provided a detailed outline of how hoofed land mammals became the sea’s largest swimmers. Birds presented a similar problem, with their origin from an unknown reptile ancestor stumping experts until some new ideas about the “terrible lizards” and amazing fossil finds proved that birds are living dinosaurs. Until recently, turtles presented an odd case similar to that of bats; the shelled reptiles seemed to appear out of nowhere in the fossil record. During the past two decades, experts have identified new species of transitional turtles and revised their opinions of already-known species to explain how turtles got their shells.
Spectacled flying fox
(CSIRO)
Each of these puzzling paleontological examples involved a major change in how the animals lived. Whales moved from the land to the ocean, birds started as terrestrial dinosaurs and took to the air and turtles were terrestrial reptiles that started burrowing underground. Bats follow the trend, undoubtedly starting from terrestrial mammal ancestors. The question is where the missing examples of early bats may be found.
“The short answer is, we don’t know why there is a missing record of ten million years,” says University of Birmingham paleontologist Emily Brown. Several factors may be at play, according to an assessment of the bat fossil record Brown and colleagues published last year.
Early bats’ choice of dwelling may have been a barrier to their preservation. “It’s previously been suggested that early bats may have predominantly lived in forested environments, which do not have very good preservation potential,” Brown says. Her survey found that the fossil record of modern bats that live in forests and jungles is largely incomplete, probably for the same reason.
The bats that modern scientists know best lived in places where rapid and delicate preservation entombed the tiny mammals. Some of the bones of Icaronycteris index, one of the earliest known bats and a neighbor of Onychonycteris, are as thin as a human hair. The only reason we know about these bats is that they lived around lakes that favored exceptional preservation; the fine sediment and oxygen-depleted water on the lake bottoms allowed fossils to be buried quickly in an environment scavengers and other decomposers couldn’t reach.
Brown says teeth make up most of the bat fossil record. Scientists often don’t have a clear picture of fossil bats unless they were preserved at exceptional sites that yield complete or articulated skeletons. It’s these types of deposits, called lagerstatten, that paleontologists will have to find to solve the mystery. The only way to understand when bats first appeared, how they evolved to fly, and more, Brown says, is to find more of these exceptional sites from rocks 50 to 66 million years old.
Icaronycteris fossil
(Wiki Commons / Andrew Savedra)
Refining our sense of what an early proto-bat might look like is also essential. The current record doesn’t offer many hints. Consider Onychonycteris, one of the oldest known bats featuring some of the most complete remains. While this mammal has more primitive limb proportions and claws on its fingers, says Royal Ontario Museum paleontologist Kevin Seymour, “it is still a bat.” The closest paleontologists can get to understanding this animal is looking at living mouse-tailed bats, Seymour notes, which use a combination of fluttering and gliding to move through the air.
What came before is only speculative. Bats are mammals, and so the earliest bats were certainly furry. Based on finds such as Onychonycteris, it’s reasonable to propose that bats went through a gliding stage before powered flight, Seymour says, and the first bats probably were insectivores. But that’s about all scientists can say with confidence without a relatively complete fossil to fill in the gap “It will certainly require articulated material,” Seymour says, relatively complete fossils acting as keystones to the tiny fossils of Paleocene and Eocene mammals that may already be resting in museums drawers.
While experts search for the relevant fossils, other mammals may offer a rough guide of what to expect. Bats may be the only mammals to evolve powered flapping flight, but other mammal species from flying squirrels to a lemur-like creature called the colugo can glide through the air on expanded membranes. The earliest bats probably evolved along a similar route, with some extra skin allowing them to move from tree to tree.
New information about existing fossils buttresses the idea that the earliest bats scampered around in the trees. In 2013, paleontologists Kevin Padian and Kenneth Dial presented research at the annual Society of Vertebrate Paleontology meeting that noted some of the earliest bats had hindlimbs that flexed to the side, rather than aligning directly beneath the body. This arrangement is more consistent with climbing rock faces and trees than walking on the ground. Searching for more tree-living beasts will help connect the fossil dots.
At least paleontologists know which time frame to investigate. Some of the oldest known bats are not single skeletons, but made up bat communities of multiple species. This means that bats were already diversifying by 50 million years ago and that their ancestors are much older–perhaps springing up after the extinction that wiped out the non-avian dinosaurs 66 million years ago. Proto-bats are going to be found in rocks from that window of time when a strange group of mammals was just starting to take wing.
It was a truism among 19th-century physicians that, in the words of German epidemiologist August Hirsch, “[t]he history of typhus … is the history of human misery.” Commonly associated at the time with the crowded and unsanitary conditions of jails, ships and hospitals, typhus attacked destitute populations mercilessly. The medical community and laypersons alike often blamed victims of the disease for their own suffering, believing that vicious, debauched, and unhygienic lifestyles begat typhus. An 1836 outbreak of typhus in Philadelphia led to important changes in how physicians understood the disease, with important lessons for epidemiology in the age of COVID-19.
During the 1800s in the United States doctors had relatively few chances to witness true epidemic typhus firsthand, and historical references to “typhus” could refer to any number of afflictions, further muddying the historical record of how pervasive the disease was. In particular, American physicians at the time believed that typhus and typhoid were the same affliction, differing only in severity of symptoms.
In reality, they are two very different illnesses. Typhus is a bacterial infection transmitted through infected body lice, while typhoid is a food-borne bacterial infection affecting the intestines. The similarity in their names was due to the fact that both diseases produced similar symptoms, including a high fever and a characteristic rash consisting of small red dots.
The first physician to definitively distinguish the two diseases, on the basis of firsthand pre- and postmortem observations, was American doctor William Wood Gerhard. Born in 1809 in Philadelphia, Gerhard was the studious eldest son of a hatter. Upon graduating from the University of Pennsylvania Medical School in 1830, Gerhard continued his medical education in Paris, where he learned clinical methods such as paying attention to both quantitative as well as qualitative sensory details when treating patients. Gerhard returned to Philadelphia in 1833 to serve as resident physician at the sick wards of the city’s almshouse, then known as the Philadelphia Hospital.
During the winter of 1835-6, a mysterious disease manifested among patients. A high fever and “dusky” expression characterized the illness, but significantly, no patients indicated intestinal problems, a common symptom of typhoid. Initially, the hospital physicians, including Gerhard, believed the disease to be bronchitis or a similar ailment. By March, it became clear that the disease, whatever it was, had become epidemic, as cases grew in number.
Blockley Almshouse, later renamed Philadelphia General Hospital, as seen from the river in 1857
The new cases “attracted the greater attention from their occurring in groups of several from the same house, and almost all coming from a particular neighbourhood,” Gerhard wrote in an 1837 article in The American Journal of the Medical Sciences. Specifically, most cases originated in a neighborhood at the southern edge of the city, extending into northern Moyamensing, an area infamous at the time for poverty and vice. But it was the density of the neighborhood, and not its economic status, that Gerhard identified as the primary contributing factor to the disease’s violence there. In departing from the common wisdom of his era, Gerhard attributed the spread of disease to physical proximity rather than moral corruption, laying the groundwork for new approaches to epidemiology.
The epidemic did not relent in 1836 as summer came—an “unusually cool” one, Gerhard remembered in his article. Gerhard applied what he had learned during his education in Paris in the early 1830s to his work in the United States during the 1836 epidemic in Philadelphia. With the help of his colleagues, including fellow Paris-educated physician Caspar Wistar Pennock, Gerhard leaned on his education to identify the disease in question as typhus. He included in his article the case of Margaret Walters, a 24-year-old assistant nurse. On March 17, having felt ill for a few days, Walters, who worked in the women’s medical ward of Philadelphia Hospital, began displaying a worrisome array of symptoms, including fever and loss of appetite. Over the next week the condition of Walters’s bowels appeared to deteriorate rapidly, despite regular enemas and sponging of the skin.
When studying in Paris, Gerhard had examined the bodies of typhoid patients, both before and after death. The intestines of typhoid patients often had inflamed or ulcerated nodules known as glands of Peyer or Peyer’s patches, named after a 17th-century Swiss anatomist. Given Walters’s symptoms, Gerhard had expected upon her death to see that her glands of Peyer were inflamed, but this was not the case; her intestinal tract was remarkably healthy. On the basis of these and similar observations, Gerhard concluded that typhus and typhoid were distinct diseases, affecting completely different parts of the body. While typhoid generated “morbid changes” of the intestines, typhus had no such effect, instead appearing to produce cognitive disturbance and muscular pains.
Gerhard estimated that the typhus epidemic affected around 250 of the Philadelphia Hospital’s patients between March and August of 1836. This number did not include those who fell ill at other institutions, or in the city at large. Most of the patients Gerhard observed were black, and Gerhard described the epidemic’s victims as primarily poor and “intemperate.” He calculated that roughly one in four of the typhus patients at the Hospital died. Black men, he noticed, seemed particularly susceptible. Gerhard attributed their vulnerability to the kinds of manual labor they typically performed, as well as their alleged drinking habits.
Initially, Gerhard and his colleagues dismissed the idea that typhus was contagious. At the time, most physicians believed few diseases were contagious; the exceptions—most notably smallpox—were those diseases observably transmissible through direct skin-to-skin contact. More often, physicians attributed diseases to “infection,” a loosely defined source of a variety of illnesses often arising from imported cargo, rather than from person-to-person transmission. As Gerhard’s familiarity with typhus increased, however, he grew to firmly believe in the disease’s contagion, emphasizing the contaminating nature of sweat; physicians did not yet know that typhus spreads through infected body louse feces. As evidence of the disease’s contagious nature from body to body, Gerhard recalled the case of a male nurse who, while shaving a dying patient, inhaled the patient’s breath. The nurse described the patient’s breath as having “a nauseous taste,” and almost immediately fell ill. Similarly, an “assistant was supporting another patient who died soon afterwards, he felt the pungent sweat [of the patient] upon his skin, and [the assistant] was taken immediately with the symptoms of typhus.”
It was clear that proximity to typhus patients put one at risk of contracting the disease. Based on his observations Gerhard concluded that, while the majority of cases were due to some unspecified environmental factor that caused the epidemic in the first place, many patients had caught the disease from someone else.
The Blockley Almshouse, later renamed Philadelphia General Hospital
In 1836, medicine was an evolving science, just as it is now, and understandings of the human body were in flux. The dynamic quality of ideas about the body left plenty of room for an inquisitive mind like Gerhard to revise how physicians interpreted various symptoms and “morbid changes.” Doing so meant having enough pre- and postmortem evidence to back up his claims, which required some patients to die. While, for better or worse, Gerhard took the credit for discovering what made typhus and typhoid distinct, it was the bodies of his nurses and patients who provided the necessary proof for his conclusions.
Physical and sensory observations exposed Gerhard and other attending caregivers to typhus’s “matter of contagion” in ways that could prove deadly. Gerhard and his colleagues did not know that typhus spreads through body lice, but they recognized anecdotally that proximity to patients put them at risk of contracting the disease. Healthcare workers during the COVID-19 pandemic find themselves similarly exposed to potentially deadly pathogens. Recognizing the virulence of the coronavirus responsible for COVID-19, public health specialists quickly began advocating “social distancing” in an effort to curtail the spread of the virus. When practiced correctly and sensitively, social (or “physical”) distancing can limit the spread of pathogens and reduce the number of people falling ill at the same time, thereby allowing healthcare workers to better care for patients who do contract the disease.
“Social distancing” as a phrase did not exist in Gerhard’s time, but the concept was well-established. For centuries, leper colonies and lazarettos had sequestered bodies and cargos suspected of carrying disease. However, 19th-century medical beliefs about contagion inclined physicians to ignore restrictions on physical closeness when providing care. Gerhard’s somewhat more expansive definition of contagion, which included transmission through bodily fluids like sweat, alerted him to the potential dangers of being in close proximity with someone suffering from typhus. Even so, he did not prompt his colleagues to maintain what he understood to be a safe distance from typhus patients. Carefully practicing social distancing might have prevented Gerhard and his colleagues from making the kinds of observations that helped them understand the differences between typhus and typhoid, but it also might have saved the lives of nurses like Margaret Walters.
Such situations might sound familiar in 2020, when shortages of personal protective equipment for healthcare workers put many on the front lines at an unnecessary risk of contracting COVID-19. In 1836, typhus spread rapidly through crowded neighborhoods of Philadelphia, primarily affecting poor people who would have had few opportunities to socially distance themselves from their neighbors, families, and roommates. Many in the United States, not to mention elsewhere, face the same set of problems in 2020. Flattening the curve was scarcely a viable option in 1836, but it is imperative in 2020, in order to protect the health and wellbeing of frontline healthcare workers, as well as those unable to practice social distancing because of the work they perform or the conditions in which they live.